Skip to content
Teams

Performance Review Bingo: Annual Review Survival

Performance review season arrives with the reliability of a natural disaster and approximately the same level of anticipatory dread. The self-assessment you should have been writing all year. The feedback sandwich. The rating that somehow doesn't match the words spoken. Performance review bingo turns review season into something you can at least find funny.

Performance Review Bingo Squares

The Self-Assessment Experience

  • Self-assessment started the night before it's due
  • Had to check Slack history to remember what you did in Q1
  • Accomplishment you forgot to document at the time
  • "What are your development areas?" causes existential crisis
  • Self-assessment that is either way too long or way too short

The Peer Feedback Cycle

  • Received feedback so vague it could describe any employee
  • Feedback from someone you barely worked with
  • "Positive" peer feedback that contains a subtle dig
  • Asked for feedback and received "keep doing what you're doing"
  • Peer review system crashes during deadline week

The Review Meeting

  • Feedback sandwich deployed — Positive, negative, positive.
  • "Development area" that is actually just a criticism
  • Rating lower than expected despite positive verbal feedback all year
  • Surprise feedback about something from eight months ago
  • "Meets expectations" explained as a compliment
  • Goal-setting for next year takes longer than reviewing this year

The Rating System Mysteries

  • Rating scale description that is impossible to distinguish between two adjacent ratings
  • "Exceeds expectations" described as rare and then given to most of the team
  • Calibration meeting mentioned as the reason a rating changed
  • Rating linked to a budget decision that has nothing to do with performance
  • "This isn't a reflection of your work" said about something that definitely is

The Aftermath

  • Goals set that are immediately forgotten
  • Development plan that requires a follow-up that never happens
  • Raise announcement that takes longer to arrive than promised
  • Coworker asks how your review went and you give a non-answer
Create Review Season Bingo

The Manager's Version of the Card

Managers have their own equally rich performance review experience. The direct report who submits a self-assessment at 11:59 PM. The peer feedback that requires editing for professionalism. The calibration meeting where everyone's ratings get adjusted. The employee who asks about their rating before you've had a chance to prep. All of it goes on the manager's card.

Making Review Season More Bearable

Share the bingo card link with your trusted work friends at the start of review season. Play in the background as you write your self-assessment, read your feedback, and navigate the meeting itself. The shared experience of marking the same squares creates community around a process that can otherwise feel very isolating.

Browse workplace bingo cards or create a custom performance review bingo card for this year's review cycle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best performance review bingo squares?
Classics: "feedback sandwich," "development area is actually just a criticism," "review was clearly written the night before," "rating is lower than expected despite positive verbal feedback all year," and "goal-setting for next year takes longer than reviewing this year."
Is performance review bingo appropriate to share with your manager?
Sharing it depends entirely on your relationship with your manager. Some managers would find it funny. Others would not. Play it for yourself and trusted peers unless you're very confident in the dynamic.
When should you run performance review bingo?
During review season — as you're completing your self-assessment, reading peer feedback, or going through the review meeting itself. The cycle usually provides enough material to complete a full card.
Can managers play performance review bingo too?
There's a rich manager-side version of the card — "direct report who won't stop asking about their rating," "self-assessment that requires significant editing before submitting upward," and "calibration meeting where your carefully considered ratings all shift." Equally satisfying.

Ready to try it?

Create your own bingo card in seconds — free, no signup required.

Create a Card